Commentary on “Rakhine nationalism and the rise of the Arakan Army”

Advocating federalism in ethnic-based multi-ethnic state has to be accompanied with ethnic equality.

 

KIA
Arakan Army leaders gather with other ethnic armed group representatives in Mai Ja Yang, a town controlled by the Kachin Independence Army on the border with China, in 2016. The AA was founded in Kachin State in 2009 with the support of the KIA. (AFP)


The present setup of 7 states and 7 divisions/regions is the first place that needs a redress. As, rightly or wrongly, the 7 regions are depicted as the areas dominantly populated by the Bamar ethnic group, which means the Bamar has 7 votes in a national decision-making process. And as such, fairness and equality in power-sharing is simply not there. Just like in the olden days after the independence from the British, from 1948 to 1962, the Bamar ethnic group has usurped the national political power in the whole union and acted as colonial master on its colonial subject.

Therefore from the 7 regions, incorporating some Bamar-dominated areas, creation of a Bamar state is needed. Others could become mixed national states, for example Rangoon region and Irrawaddy regions where ethnic groups are mixed with Karen and Mon; and Tanintharyi or Tenasserim where the Tavoyen are also mixed with Karen and Mon.

That was why there was a Federal Amendment Proposal in 1961 drawn by the endorsement of all ethnic nationalities, popularly known as Shan Proposal for it was spear headed by the Shan government and held in Taunggyi, which was tabled and discussed in the parliament in 1962. On 2 March 1962 the military launched a coup stating that the country is about to disintegrate, when in fact this was a last attempt to settle the political disagreement through peaceful political means.

The next thing is correcting the wrong concept of the Bamar political class and the Bamar-dominated military that today Burma is the continuation of the three Burmese empire, which the Global New Light of Myanmar labeled as the fourth union (it doesn’t use the word empire but the meaning is clear) built by Gen Aung San. In contrast, the non-Bamar ethnic nationalities see the country today as a new political entity established by virtue of Panglong Agreement voluntarily signed on 12 February 1947 between the Federated Shan States, Kachin and Chin Hills and the Burma Proper, which Karen, Mon and Arakan were also included during the British colonial period.

Without correcting the two said wrong views, there is little or no hope to build a successful union, as they are core obstacles that sent the ethnic nationalities into resistance, revolutionary mode in the first place.
 

Leave a Comments

promotion

SHAN Membership

฿ 19฿ 169 /mo
  • ၶဝ်ႈႁူမ်ႈ ႁဵၼ်းဢဝ်ၵၢၼ်ၶၢဝ်ႇ၊ ရေႊတီႊဢူဝ်ႊ၊ ထႆႇႁၢင်ႈ၊ Blogger, Vlog ထႆႇဝီႊတီႊဢူဝ်ႊ တတ်းတေႃႇ ႁဵတ်းဢွၵ်ႇ ပိုၼ်ၽႄႈ
  • ၶဝ်ႈႁူမ်ႈၵၢၼ်တူင်ႉၼိုင်ၸုမ်းၶၢဝ်ႇၽူႈတွႆႇႁွၵ်ႈ ၼႂ်းၶၵ်ႉၵၢၼ်ပူၵ်းပွင်ၵၢၼ်သိုဝ်ႇ
  • ၶဝ်ႈႁူမ်ႈပၢင်လႅၵ်ႈလၢႆႈပိုၼ်ႉႁူႉပၢႆးႁၼ် ဢၼ်ၸုမ်းၶၢဝ်ႇၽူႈတွႆႇႁွၵ်ႈၸတ်းႁဵတ်း
  • ၶဝ်ႈႁူမ်ႈပၢင်ဢုပ်ႇဢူဝ်းတွင်ႈထၢမ် ၵဵဝ်ႇၵပ်းငဝ်းလၢႆးၵၢၼ်မိူင်း၊ ၵၢၼ်မၢၵ်ႈမီး၊ ပၢႆးမွၼ်း လႄႈ ႁူဝ်ၶေႃႈ ဢၼ်ၶႂ်ႈႁူႉၶႂ်ႈငိၼ်း။
  • လႆႈႁပ်ႉဢၢၼ်ႇ ၶၢဝ်ႇၶိုၵ်ႉတွၼ်း ပိူင်ပဵၼ်ဝူင်ႈလႂ်ဝူင်ႈ ၼၼ်ႉ။

Related article

Latest article

Min Zin, director of the Myanmar Institute for Strategy and Policy (ISP Myanmar) (Photo Courtesy)

SILENCING THE SCHOLAR: The Strategic Message Behind China’s Arrest of U Min Zin

0
Beijing’s detention of U Min Zin is not merely a legal maneuver; it is a calculated warning to the entire ecosystem of independent analysis...
Villagers affected by land confiscations gather in Hopong Township, southern Shan State, to protest the seizure of their land and homes (Photo Supplied)

Land Seizure Victims in Hopong Face New Fees to Destroy Former Homes

0
Residents of Nyaung Bat Village in Hopong Township say they are facing a final indignity in an ongoing land confiscation campaign: being forced by...
Damage caused by the warehouse explosion in Kawng Tap Village, Namkham Township (Photo Supplied)

Deadly Namkham Warehouse Blast Sparks Calls for Accountability

0
Residents of Namkham Township are demanding accountability from the Ta'ang National Liberation Army (TNLA) and the Chinese government following a massive explosion at a...
Peter Bar in Taunggyi, southern Shan State, where the incident leading to the death of 16 year old

Teenage Bar Worker Dies in Taunggyi, Sparking Calls for Justice

0
The death of a 16-year-old girl at a bar in Taunggyi has sparked renewed concern over child labor, workplace abuse, and the lack of...
Shanni delegates (Photo Courtesy)

THE SHANNI DILEMMA: Survival, Alliances, and the Struggle for Self-Determination

0
On the morning of May 4, the National Unity and Peacemaking Coordinating Committee (NSPNC) and the Shanni Nationalities Army (SNA), together with Shanni Nationalities...