THINK PIECE: An unjust peace is better than a just war

[dropcap color=”#dd9933″]W[/dropcap]ith the Union Peace Conference – 21st Century Panglong scheduled to be held on July 11, 2018, it is high time that all stakeholders give a second thought to the ethnic armed organizations’ proposition of applying “conditional clause” since the last conference a year ago, as a way out of the peace process stagnation and deadlock.

 

Sai Wansai

  • From this outgoing point the unjust peace could be viewed by the non-Bamar ethnic nationalities, as having to give up some of their aspirations, say agreeing to the non-secession clause of the Bamar Military’s demand.
  • From the Bamar Military point of view, the unjust peace would be taken as having to agree to the proposition of the ethnic armed organizations’ (EAOs) federal army formation guided by the security sector reform (SSR), rather than the disarmament, demobilization, and reintegration (DDR) and maintenance of its Bamar-dominated standard army.
  • On wagging a just war, the EAOs would argue that they are defending their ancestors homelands and thus it is a justified resistance war.
  • But for the Bamar Military, rightly or wrongly, it is convinced that all the ethnic states have been part and parcel of its Burmese empire since time immemorial and thus is entitled to crush all resistance groups that rebelled against its domination, to maintain territorial integrity and sovereignty, which are its sole ownership and responsibility.
  • Thus, both camps see that they are wagging a just war from their own perspectives.
  • If it is so, couldn’t the adversaries agree at least on maintaining an unjust peace by compromising, using conditional clauses to be able to reach an agreement ?
  • By conditional it is meant for example regarding the non-secession issue, the ethnic nationalities would agree that they will not secede if the agreeable and acceptable federal democracy is adhered by the Bamar-dominated powers that be, if not they have the right to nullify the “holding together” agreement and secede.
  • The same goes of the establishment of a federal army, which means if the territorial integrity of each ethnic state is guaranteed and proportionate participation in the federal army only for the purpose of the country’s protection from external enemies are honored, the non-Bamar ethnic nationalities will abide by the federal union setup, if not they have the right to opt out of it.
  • In sum, the crucial point for all stakeholders to grasp is that negotiation deadlock could be overcome only by making use of the conditional clauses, where necessary to avoid “win-lose” contest and usher in a “win-win” oriented out comes.

Leave a Comments

promotion

SHAN Membership

฿ 19฿ 169 /mo
  • ၶဝ်ႈႁူမ်ႈ ႁဵၼ်းဢဝ်ၵၢၼ်ၶၢဝ်ႇ၊ ရေႊတီႊဢူဝ်ႊ၊ ထႆႇႁၢင်ႈ၊ Blogger, Vlog ထႆႇဝီႊတီႊဢူဝ်ႊ တတ်းတေႃႇ ႁဵတ်းဢွၵ်ႇ ပိုၼ်ၽႄႈ
  • ၶဝ်ႈႁူမ်ႈၵၢၼ်တူင်ႉၼိုင်ၸုမ်းၶၢဝ်ႇၽူႈတွႆႇႁွၵ်ႈ ၼႂ်းၶၵ်ႉၵၢၼ်ပူၵ်းပွင်ၵၢၼ်သိုဝ်ႇ
  • ၶဝ်ႈႁူမ်ႈပၢင်လႅၵ်ႈလၢႆႈပိုၼ်ႉႁူႉပၢႆးႁၼ် ဢၼ်ၸုမ်းၶၢဝ်ႇၽူႈတွႆႇႁွၵ်ႈၸတ်းႁဵတ်း
  • ၶဝ်ႈႁူမ်ႈပၢင်ဢုပ်ႇဢူဝ်းတွင်ႈထၢမ် ၵဵဝ်ႇၵပ်းငဝ်းလၢႆးၵၢၼ်မိူင်း၊ ၵၢၼ်မၢၵ်ႈမီး၊ ပၢႆးမွၼ်း လႄႈ ႁူဝ်ၶေႃႈ ဢၼ်ၶႂ်ႈႁူႉၶႂ်ႈငိၼ်း။
  • လႆႈႁပ်ႉဢၢၼ်ႇ ၶၢဝ်ႇၶိုၵ်ႉတွၼ်း ပိူင်ပဵၼ်ဝူင်ႈလႂ်ဝူင်ႈ ၼၼ်ႉ။

Related article

Latest article

Min Zin, director of the Myanmar Institute for Strategy and Policy (ISP Myanmar) (Photo Courtesy)

SILENCING THE SCHOLAR: The Strategic Message Behind China’s Arrest of U Min Zin

0
Beijing’s detention of U Min Zin is not merely a legal maneuver; it is a calculated warning to the entire ecosystem of independent analysis...
Villagers affected by land confiscations gather in Hopong Township, southern Shan State, to protest the seizure of their land and homes (Photo Supplied)

Land Seizure Victims in Hopong Face New Fees to Destroy Former Homes

0
Residents of Nyaung Bat Village in Hopong Township say they are facing a final indignity in an ongoing land confiscation campaign: being forced by...
Damage caused by the warehouse explosion in Kawng Tap Village, Namkham Township (Photo Supplied)

Deadly Namkham Warehouse Blast Sparks Calls for Accountability

0
Residents of Namkham Township are demanding accountability from the Ta'ang National Liberation Army (TNLA) and the Chinese government following a massive explosion at a...
Peter Bar in Taunggyi, southern Shan State, where the incident leading to the death of 16 year old

Teenage Bar Worker Dies in Taunggyi, Sparking Calls for Justice

0
The death of a 16-year-old girl at a bar in Taunggyi has sparked renewed concern over child labor, workplace abuse, and the lack of...
Shanni delegates (Photo Courtesy)

THE SHANNI DILEMMA: Survival, Alliances, and the Struggle for Self-Determination

0
On the morning of May 4, the National Unity and Peacemaking Coordinating Committee (NSPNC) and the Shanni Nationalities Army (SNA), together with Shanni Nationalities...